Fracturing Chemistry

Flowback Troubleshooting: What’s Really in the Gel?

By PureChem Frac Technical Team 3 min read
Collage of fracturing chemistry work: red mineral veins, blue fluid, a gloved hand grinding with a mortar and pestle, a field technician mixing at chemical drums, amber gel, fractured rock with an electric spark and white powder

When something unexpected shows up in flowback, the first assumption is usually a chemical incompatibility. In this article we walk through a recent flowback gel investigation and the testing sequence we use to find the root cause.

Key Takeaways
  • A gel showing up in flowback is not always caused by incompatible chemical packages.
  • Lab testing can identify what the gel is made of and help find the root cause.
  • Compatibility testing before the job can help prevent flowback issues.

Introduction

During a drill out on a multi-well pad, a thick gel started building up around the milling tools and affecting flowback. The pad had two chemical packages in play: a frac package, and a separate coil package from a different vendor. A new FR was being trialed at the same time. The question from the operator was a fair one: is there an incompatibility between the chemistries, and is the new FR to blame?

Step 1: Gather Everything

Before running a single test, collect a sample of the gel along with samples of every chemical pumped on the pad, and the loadings for both packages. In this case we received the neat gel and ten chemical samples, and used a baseline water for comparison.

Step 2: Characterize the Sample

Normally the first step is to centrifuge the sample to separate the liquid and solid phases. This sample had no free liquid, so that step was skipped. Visually, it was a beige, hydrated, concentrated polymer with a faint hydrocarbon smell, some dark flakes and grains throughout, and almost no resistance to breaking apart by hand.

Next is solubility. The sample was washed with organic solvents (hexane, xylene and chloroform) and was 0% soluble, so no oil-based or organic carryover. It was then washed in 15% HCl, where it was 99.2% soluble. Had a large insoluble portion remained, the next step would be XRD and EDX to identify scale, fines or corrosion products, but that was not needed here.

Step 3: FTIR

FTIR identifies functional groups by which wavelengths of infrared light a sample absorbs. Suspecting a polymer, the lab compared the gel against lab mixes of the chemicals pumped on location. The closest match was the guar from the coil package after contact with water. Very little FR signature was present, and the organic solvent washes showed nothing beyond the solvents themselves.

Step 4: NMR

Nuclear Magnetic Resonance (NMR) was run on both the organic extract and the aqueous phase. The organic extract matched the reference solvent mixture to about 99%, confirming no frac package chemistry carried over. The aqueous phase was dominated by water, with two small peaks in the sugar region characteristic of guar and no detectable polyacrylamide FR. Diluting the sample further did not change the water peak, meaning the water was bound inside the gel rather than added during prep. In other words, a hydrated guar.

Step 5: Compatibility Testing

Finally, the frac and coil packages were mixed 50:50 at their field loadings and held at ambient and at bottomhole temperature for two hours. No incompatibility showed up at either temperature.

Step 6: Confirm with an Enzyme Breaker

As a final check, the neat gel was placed in an enzyme breaker solution, and it broke down very nicely. Enzyme breakers target the guar backbone and do little to a polyacrylamide FR, so a clean break is one more piece of evidence pointing to guar. It also tells you how to clean the problem up in the field.

Wrapping It Up

The gel on the milling tools was predominantly hydrated guar from the coil package, not a reaction between vendor chemistries and not the new FR. Without the testing, the new FR could easily have taken the blame. When something does show up in flowback, a structured sequence of characterization, solubility, FTIR, NMR, compatibility and breaker testing gets you to the root cause instead of an assumption.

Better yet is not needing the troubleshooting at all. That means asking the right questions up front: what is each vendor pumping, at what loadings, how do the packages interact, and what happens to a guar sweep left behind in the wellbore? Pre-job compatibility testing and a plan for breaking and cleaning up polymer can keep this off the milling tools.

More on fluid testing and flowback analysis in upcoming posts.

Have a Technical Challenge
We Haven't Covered?

Our team works directly with operators across the WCSB. If you are dealing with a specific formation challenge, fluid compatibility issue, or completions question, we want to hear it.

Talk to Our Technical Team