Fracturing Chemistry

Rheology: What Are You Optimizing For?

By PureChem Frac Technical Team 4 min read
Collage of rheology and lab testing: a chemist at a laboratory bench, fluid with suspended bubbles, a branching fracture pattern, gloved hands handling sample vials in a rack, a glowing crack in dark rock and a droplet falling from a pipette

Where does your cp number come from, what testing verifies it, and does the lab test match field conditions?

Key Takeaways
  • Ask where your cp number came from and what testing confirms it.
  • Viscosity at 300 rpm alone does not tell you how well an FR will carry proppant.
  • Hydration time, shear history, and bob size all change the reported cp.

Introduction

When screening FRs, rheology is usually one of the first things on the list. The question in this post is what rheology you are actually optimizing for.

Where Does 20cp Come From?

In the WCSB, a lot of operators ask for 20cp at 511 s-1 from experience. Fair question is why that number, and what testing confirmed it. The literature does not land on one cp target. One study found that viscosity at 300 rpm, and more recently at lower shear rates, gets used to pick HVFRs, but those numbers on their own do not tell you if the fluid will carry proppant [1]. So where did your cp number come from? A previous program, a field trial, a data sheet?

Stokes’ Law

The common reasoning for chasing viscosity is Stokes’ law, where the settling velocity of proppant is inversely proportional to the viscosity of the fluid [2]. One thing to consider is that Stokes’ law assumes a single particle settling slowly in a simple fluid, and is generally not valid at higher Reynolds numbers or where proppant is clustering [2]. Proppant settling in a fracture also sees a much lower shear rate than 511 s-1, and FRs are shear thinning. Is the viscosity being reported the same viscosity that is carrying your sand?

Young’s Modulus and Initiation

Another thing to consider is the rock itself, and one way to think about it is Calgary’s roads. A higher viscosity fluid tends to build something closer to Stoney Trail, a wider, more direct fracture that drives straight across natural fractures instead of turning into them. Slickwater is more like the side streets in the Beltline, narrower paths that open up the natural fractures and branch out into a network. The rock decides how wide a road you can build. Softer rock allows for more width, while stiffer rock with a higher Young’s modulus gives a narrower fracture for the same net pressure. Neither one is right or wrong, it depends on whether your formation needs a highway or a street network, and whether your proppant can fit down the road you built.

Is there a certain cp needed for initiation and to open enough width to accept proppant in your formation, and was the 20cp number set with your rock properties in mind?

Hydration Time and Pump Time

Many labs report 5 to 10 min hydration times before reading rheology on an OFITE or Brookfield, mixing in a Waring blender or paddle mixer and passing it between beakers until the 5 or 10 min mark. Check whether 5 min and 10 min readings actually differ. Surface hydration and pump time may not match that lab procedure, so what you pump downhole can be different from the number on the report.

Shear History

Shear history is the other gap. Field fluid sees pipe shear; a lot of lab samples sit still or get poured between beakers. How different is a reading after 5 to 10 min of shear versus a sample that hydrated with almost none? Montgomery had a borate crosslinked fluid at 800cp with no shear history, and about 20cp after 5 min at 2200 s-1 [2].

Bob Size

Another thing to verify is the specific bob size being used on your rheometer. 511 s-1 is 300 rpm on an R1B1 setup, so a different bob at the same rpm is a different shear rate.

Wrapping It Up

There is not much standardization here, which is how a lab cp can come in well above what that FR does once it is in the pipe. Where did your cp number come from, what testing verifies it, and do the lab tests match field conditions as closely as they can? Are the submitted tests using the same bob, the same hydration procedure, the same shear history, and loadings that actually hit the specified cp?

References

  1. Does Higher Viscosity Improve Proppant Transport? SPE Oklahoma City Oil and Gas Symposium, 2019. OnePetro.
  2. Montgomery, C. 2013. Fracturing Fluids. In Effective and Sustainable Hydraulic Fracturing. InTech. https://doi.org/10.5772/56192

More on fluid testing and FR selection in upcoming posts.

Have a Technical Challenge
We Haven't Covered?

Our team works directly with operators across the WCSB. If you are dealing with a specific formation challenge, fluid compatibility issue, or completions question, we want to hear it.

Talk to Our Technical Team